PALM BEACH, FLORIDA - JANUARY 3: (EDITOR'S NOTE: This Handout image was provided by a third-party organization and may not adhere to Getty Images' editorial policy.) U.S. President Donald Trump, CIA Director John Ratcliffe (L) and Secretary of State Marco Rubio monitor U.S. military operations in Venezuela, from Trump's Mar-a-Lago Club on January 3, 2026 in Palm Beach, Florida. President of Venezuela Nicolas Maduro and first lady Cilia Flores were brought to New York on Saturday after being captured by the U.S. military in Caracas. They are expected to face federal charges related to drug trafficking and working with gangs designated as terrorist organizations.
Molly Riley/The White House via Getty
President Donald Trump’s military intervention in Venezuela claimed more lives than initially suspected, according to the country’s interior minister. Diosdado Cabello said on Wednesday that the operation to extricate dictator Nicolás Maduro and his wife claimed the lives of 100 people, despite the U.S. placing the initial death toll at 75, The Washington Post reports. “So far—and I say so far—there are 100 dead. One hundred. And a similar number injured,” he said. It is the first time Caracas has put a number on its dead, previously only stating the names of 23 slain service members, while Cuba, too, said 32 of its military personnel had died in the attack. Reuters reports that Venezuela also said large numbers of Maduro’s security detail were killed “in cold blood.” Cabello commenced a week of mourning for the fallen troops on Tuesday. CNBC reports that the Pentagon said seven U.S. service members were injured in the operation, five have recovered, and no fatalities have been announced.
Yes, hit the wires a few hours ago, I've been out. May he get a lifelong of unrest, there's not a place in the United State that he will be unidentifiable. I bet you, he's placed in a special relocation zone, outside of the continental. They're going to protect him at all costs.
The latest attempt to sanitize the murder is to use Ross’ previous experience of being dragged by a car as an excuse for being triggered. This is exactly why due process is so important, it is for the safety of all including the agents. NOEM is responsible for allowing due process to be violated. I have repeatedly written to my congressman members about the loss of due process and habeas corpus in immigration enforcement. The failure of GOPCongress to enforce this was the beginning of their succession from their duty. Abandoning the constitution, they left us while pretending so be our representatives. They are guilty also. This will continue to put agents in extremely compromised positions.
The ICE murderers name is Johnathan Ross. I believe the regime is protecting and has him in hiding. This is the second time he’s violated the law against an American citizen. In my opinion he needs hunted down, put him in jail until he’s put on trial for murder.
Yes, hit the wires a few hours ago, I've been out. May he get a lifelong of unrest, there's not a place in the United State that he will be unidentifiable. I bet you, he's placed in a special relocation zone, outside of the continental. They're going to protect him at all costs.
thank you... he must be ID'd. The hotels housing these nazi need to cancel their reservations immediately. Everyone should know where these goons are staying
That is exactly what I said. I don't care where they lay their head at night time, somebody needs to find out and a bunch of people need to either go there and start protesting and being loud or just driving by and blowing their horns keep the son of a bitches up all night long
I am delighted to hear that there are Articles of Impeachment for Noem. I know that you will be following that as you do everything important. Thanks for your consistently excellent journalism.
Great reporting, we need anything which could lead to him. But notice, no donors, no money. It's an ignored request with only a pic from the internet. Nothing on the internet to validate Marc Vojnic as being in Minnesota or an agent, it's a unique enough name that something would come up. I say it's b.s. somebody trying to capitalize on MAGA stupidity not to check it out and simply give over the red hat dollars; I applaud it, they are stupid enough to actually give. If you've been traveling the internet, there are people glorifying him and vilifying Renee. THEY ARE THAT STUPID!
JUST LIKE THE VILLAINS IN THE EPSTEIN FILES, ACCOUNTABILITY IS A LIE. not every popsicle agent is following Criminal orders but putting 3 in the dome for traffic violations or federal crimes, is terrorism and we stop terrorists and violence in our homes, work places, airports & schools when it's happening. we don't "document and record". left&right are protected under 2A & it's our American duty to take necessary action to protect ourselves. our police officers aren't putting 3 in the dome for everyone who makes traffic violations or carries/under the influence of substances that are federal crimes. there are consequences to not following orders but 3 to the dome isnt one of them. we stop it at home, stop it at school and stop it in our airports. white skin and a mask does not prevent someone from being a threat. especially when that threat is so conspicuous and public. 2A isn't reserved for MAGA extremist with government jobs. Justice isnt reserved for the wealthy. you're worried about martial law but he already has all the power: he controls schools/universities, religion, lawyers, judicial branch, the military, the house, biggest monopoly corporations & the media. Earthlings stand up to terrorism regardless of skin, mask & jobs titles & we have 2A to thank for that. RIP Charlie Kirk
In respect to all the video available, there is no doubt as to which agent on site shot Renee. As I stated, this is a computer composite of his face unmasked from the video taken. Photo editing using AI has leaped to outrageous heights in just the last year; it is possible he has a goatee, beard, mustache but, the shape is essentially going to be on target. My hope is somebody knows an ice agent that looks essentially like the guy in the photo. We need to do the work ourselves since, as of the news reports this morning, Minneapolis AND Minnesota law enforcement has been officially locked out of the investigation or even getting any information on the investigation; it has been handed solely to the FBI. You already know the circus and joke that investigation is going to be!
The guy shot her three times! Once through the windshield and then moved over to shoot her two times through the drivers window. This was an execution, plain and simple. Three times, point blank.
Yes, unless this ICE officer said something about wanting to kill someone -- even a general comment -- ahead of this event. That would be sorted out at trial, of course.
He didn't shoot her just once to disable her. He shot her three times to end her and it was his choice to do so. To me , that is not manslaughter but rather murder. i.e. the killing was not accidental.
I saw the horrific video and thought the reaction by ICE was clearly uncalled for . I am so saddened by this murder by a hardened professional with a gun and a willingness to kill with reckless abandon, it would seem. How will this be explained to the children? They are going to need much counselling ,as will others in the family, to deal with the rage and unimaginable grief after something like this, as hate foments hate .
Hate is hate! Our division will not be resolved through more hate. I know it’s hard, I do, but there’s a better way forward that doesn’t make us hate those we disagree with or dislike.
Really? Whether you like it or not, a lot of social and political progress has been achieved PRECISELY because of hate.
One caveat was - it was great hate combined with great love. When slaves and people who took up their cause fought against slavery, it wasn't because they found slavery mildly inconvenient. They hated it. That great hate was combined with great love for their fellow humans and their freedom.
Women didn't get beaten and imprisoned because they thought their lack of rights was a mere nuisance - they HATED the fact that they were being treated as inferior beings.
Right now, my fellow Ukrainians are not fighting Russia because they are annoyed - they hate that some big bully came barging into their country, committed hideous atrocities, and wants to get away with it and then some. This hate too is combined with their great love of their land and their independence.
Hate has its place - and I strongly believe it has its place here and now. We SHOULD hate these people for what they have done and what they continue to do. Because we also love those, whom they abuse and oppress. We SHOULD hate autocracy. We SHOULD hate abuse of power. Pretending like it's a mere disagreement is not going to get us anywhere. This is a serious problem and it will not be solved by the "let's all hold hands - we are still friends" attitude. We are talking about human rights violations here. That is not just a disagreement or dislike.
You make some valid points on the power that drives change. You’re not wrong on several points regarding the duality of love and hate. However, I have pursued much inspiration from the civil right movement of the 60s, specifically the approach taken by Dr. MLK, Jr. who also understood the corrosion of hate on a community and on individuals. How are we better than the hate driving ICE agents to mistreat, abuse, and harm people if we also support similar hate ourselves?
Not similar hate. They hate people for things outside of people's control. We hate them for what they do because of it. People have no choice in where they are born, or what color they are, or what sexual orientation. ICE agents have a choice whether to be what they are or not.
Hate is not the same as anger. Anger fueled by attack or threat to someone or something you love can strengthen resolve and motivate to constructive action. Hate is hardened anger that has lost its way.
I hate Putin, Trump, and a few other people, and I know exactly why. I haven't lost my way. Some people deserve to be hated and I am happy to provide that service. If my refusal to shy away from hate and what it entails makes anyone uncomfortable - you are free not to join me. I have a great capacity for hate and a great capacity for love, and I embrace both.
Yup, that's what I've been comparing them to as well. And we have no reason not to hate cancer. I lost my mom to a bone tumor, lost friends to cancer as well. I hate what it does and I want it gone. Its only saving grace is - it doesn't know what it's doing, but THESE people do. Which makes it worse.
Gee, thanks a lot! Because, obviously, you know everything about me and what I do and it is TOTALLY the same as hunting immigrants for sport and shooting innocent civilians. Well done! Enjoy piling more people into the same bucket!
Maria, I feel for you and your country as you have had to deal with so much injustice by the Russians led by Putin , to the enrichment of the oligarchs that he pays homage to. Your hate , and that of your country , has obviously kept you fighting for your freedom to be a sovereign country for many years now.
My heart tells me to stand up to the wrong being done now in our country with righteous resolve and determination to right wrongs being perpetrate in our country by hateful Christian Nationalists people who love to hate and live to hate on a daily basis.
We, as Americans, must not become like them.
What I see as the solution to all of what is happening is to stand united as We,The People , against a fascist regime that wishes to overtake us and become our overlords for their own personal enrichment . Protests are a good thing and when done within the law and in an orderly manner can be a starting point toward a more just society by energizing voters to get the facts straight on the current issues that we are all facing in our country and vote out the trouble makers and vote in the sound thinkers who wish for a fair and equitable life in our country in accord with our Preamble, our Constitution and our Bill of Rights.
I'm with you and your people in your fight for these things and I want the best for you and yours for many years to come.
Thank you. I am actually in the States - I am a first-generation Ukrainian-American. My parents are in the war-torn, daily-bombed Zaporizhzhya, and I can't get them out. Meanwhile, they are worried about me because I am a female neurodivergent immigrant living in the United States today - the LAST thing they should be worrying about, really, since they get shelled every day.
I am very aware and am part of the resistance effort here - supporting indie journalists like Aaron here, daily educating people about the situation in Ukraine, writing to my representatives, etc.
So, I am having double the fun wondering if my parents are still alive on an hourly basis and getting my personal share of hate for being an immigrant. All because of certain people's drive for money and power. I do not advocate violence - although, I am 100% rooting for my step-mom who said that, if Russians come barging into Zaporizhzhya, she would fight them off with her favorite cast iron frying pan. However, I reserve my right to hate and channel that feeling in whatever way I see necessary.
RIGHT NOW, people are trying to protect their families,neighbors,friends from danger. That's the opposite of the hate that you speak of. They are doing as we are told to do," LOVE ❤️ thy neighbor."
The original comment was about wishing no peace on the accused gunman or his family for the rest of their lives. That’s not love or a viable solution to our division. You’re right, love is the answer but we must also provide it to those seemingly unworthy of our love and compassion to rise above the hate driving these horrific crimes! The point is that our anger, fear, and frustration, among other things, can result in hate within ourselves as well, which is not the way!
The gunman had just destroyed a family, a neighborhood, and a circle of friends. At the very least, I hope his family walks away from him and his friends turn away from him, and he goes to jail for murder.
Sadly, the powers that be are already spinning this as "self defense" and slandering the murdered woman as "disorderly" and the person who filmed the video - a "professional agitator".
The hatred that “is driving these horrific crimes” was started and continues to be fed by donald trump. His “truth social” rants to his followers and his public statements drive the hatred. There is something inside of these people who follow him and commit these atrocities that matches his anger and hatred. Whether it is a feeling of being displaced in the work place or bigotry against non white people, I don’t know. Right now these people are full of hate and are complicit with these crimes.
You can’t know what the rest of his family’s political persuasion is yet so until you find out, they fairly shouldn’t be included. You know there are millions of divided family political views in this horrible time. Then if it’s found out they inspired this mentality… go for it!
That little boy, age 6, is now an orphan. His father, and the husband of his mother, died a few years ago.
The ICE “agents” are thugs. Look at all of the examples we have seen of their actions. They show no compassion at all for those that they grab off the streets, leaving children alone, without parents.
(I made an error, her child is a boy. I corrected it. )
The upsetting thing is that they get away with it___the government has done nothing to improve the situation for almost a year_____it reallly is inhumane____the victims are human beings !!!
I have been reading that she had three children. The six year old was probably the youngest that she was dropping off at school or day care. Thank god she didn't have him in the car.
Also thank god that she didn't hit someone else and kill or injure them when she crashed. THAT'S would have been on the ICE agent.
Joseph, I was answering the earlier post above that said that the ICE shooter’s family should know no peace for the rest of their lives.
Him? Absolutely!
We don’t know anything about his family so I feel we shouldn’t be judging them until all the facts are revealed about him, the monster who created this moral and criminal disaster. Families nowadays are so divided in their beliefs so we should wait and see if they’re in league with him. Then feel free to express your wishes if they were like minded to his ideals.
I submit that some people are just born with psychological disorders that exhibit themselves through the abhorrent behavior of many of the Nazi types in the world , in my opinion.
The lady's family in Minnesota should file a lawsuit against Trump and Nome sue Trump for $500 Million for murder, and NOME for $500 Million for murder. These goons have to be stopped before more people are killed without cause.
Lock Donald Trump up before more people are killed.;
Trump Has Killed More People Than First Realized
SO FAR...
PALM BEACH, FLORIDA - JANUARY 3: (EDITOR'S NOTE: This Handout image was provided by a third-party organization and may not adhere to Getty Images' editorial policy.) U.S. President Donald Trump, CIA Director John Ratcliffe (L) and Secretary of State Marco Rubio monitor U.S. military operations in Venezuela, from Trump's Mar-a-Lago Club on January 3, 2026 in Palm Beach, Florida. President of Venezuela Nicolas Maduro and first lady Cilia Flores were brought to New York on Saturday after being captured by the U.S. military in Caracas. They are expected to face federal charges related to drug trafficking and working with gangs designated as terrorist organizations.
Molly Riley/The White House via Getty
President Donald Trump’s military intervention in Venezuela claimed more lives than initially suspected, according to the country’s interior minister. Diosdado Cabello said on Wednesday that the operation to extricate dictator Nicolás Maduro and his wife claimed the lives of 100 people, despite the U.S. placing the initial death toll at 75, The Washington Post reports. “So far—and I say so far—there are 100 dead. One hundred. And a similar number injured,” he said. It is the first time Caracas has put a number on its dead, previously only stating the names of 23 slain service members, while Cuba, too, said 32 of its military personnel had died in the attack. Reuters reports that Venezuela also said large numbers of Maduro’s security detail were killed “in cold blood.” Cabello commenced a week of mourning for the fallen troops on Tuesday. CNBC reports that the Pentagon said seven U.S. service members were injured in the operation, five have recovered, and no fatalities have been announced.
Read it at Reuters
Get back on Jeffrey Epstein files and the raping of underage girls by Epstein and his friends
Echo-I agree the ICE officer (Gestapo) should know no peace, but his wife and kids?Really?They are not guilty by association. They are not guilty at all.
This should NEVER have happened. These thugs escalated the situation instead of defusing it. Why put yourself into a situation that is a direct line to discharging your firearm?? Step away let the vehicle leave, you have the license plate number, arrest when it's safe for all. These thugs are trigger-happy goons. An independent entity needs to gather as many videos possible and analyze completely. Get a warrant for the medical record of this thug before this administration gets it and alters it. They hopefully made him relinquish his firearm until a full and independent and complete investigation is performed.
He’ll probably get a bonus, if noem or trump have their way. These actions are to tell those who could protest and make a difference: your actions will not be tolerated, and you may pay for your opposition with your life.
Keith Ellison was just on CNN and the state law enforcement that supposed to work in conjunction with the FBI have been told to stand down. Gestapo regime tactics. My hope is eventually when the FBI finishes their fake investigation local and state law enforcement will do their investigations. Eventually this murderer will be held accountable. We should definitely try find out who it is.
It's my understanding that Kristi Noam said he shot her in self defense, as she was going to hit him and anybody else in her attempt to escape, is the rationale for his actions. Video review would reveal otherwise. I saw the video and she actually tried to steer away from him after he made the first shot and got out of the way to go to her driver side window and shoot her twice in the head.
She's fake on the inside and most definitely on the outside. Her body can't anymore plastic surgery botox or lip fillers she's gross in more ways than one!
Yes, and hold his manager and his manager's manager to account for setting up conditions so that someone would get hurt. He did wrong, but he's a pawn. Don't let the managers get away with it. They'll just go ahead and send other pawns in, and more people will get hurt. Unnecessarily, needlessly hurt.
Her 6 year old has a parent. Renee has a wife surviving her. She miraculously survived the shooting in the car although she was sprayed with her wife’s blood.
Yes. Renee was widowed in 2023 and the child is from that union but thank goodness the child still has a parent right now. I read early on an interview of her wife who sat on a nearby curb clutching their dog who said she didn’t know what she was going to do, that they had a 6 year old in school…and the blood. This is the person draped over and holding Renee sobbing in videos after the car had hit the pole. And yes, she is a first hand witness who said they had only stopped to video ICE. I can only think her shock, privacy protection, safety from nut jobs, and protection against ICE (who might try to arrest her as “complicit” in some way because they have labeled their victim Renee as a terrorist) is why the circumstances of her presence and existence is not generally known. Can you imagine Minnesotan locals (mayor) setting the trap for ICE lies by keeping the main eyewitness under protection and quiet until she can spring the truth on the murderer in a court?
I'm sorry. I didn't know about her wife being there. I read so many news articles that are not consistent, including the name of her mother (2 different names). He does have a grandfather who spends time with the little boy. He said that he's the only man in his grandson's Iife. I didn't watch the video because I can't handle that. Thank you for all the info. So heartbreaking. I really hate this entire administration. They are evil.
No apologies necessary. The reporter on site could have misunderstood too. 😢 we’re all very sad and angry. And it’s probably a good thing for you not to tattoo those images on your brain. I already have all the regrets. I knew Alito’s mother who exposed the corruption to me during the 80’s (which came to pass just as she told me it would), and tRump owes me money from back then too. Thank goodness I was warned away from him and his crowd when I used to go to NY. I knew Forbes Sr (who was generous unlike his tight son who even tried to have his gay father committed to get the $). I did some protesting when I was young and I was also beat up (before Rodney King or videos, but I won all my cases and the largest settlement of its kind to that date in that state). I have all this corruption and the inside of the beehive in my neurons already. Bedminster (which is a town between Oldwick and Peapack-Gladstone/Bernardsville where now he owns that golf course) was one of my stomping grounds. All these things being perpetrated on all of us are disillusioning, very real, and have been going on for decades. My heart breaks anew for poor Renee. I can barely handle what her last moments must have been like for her when they murdered her and stole her life.
I hope not with my whole heart. That mayor should be providing her and the kid(s) with meaningful protection who won’t look the other way or cave to feds.
My guess they haven’t turned him over yet is because they are trying to hide him. They know he will be tried for murder and the Republicans don’t want that optic. Anybody know someone who has access to facial recognition? That’s about the fastest way to find him unless someone knows him and thinks he is a POS. A Trump POS belongs in the trash heap of history.
I don't know anyone else I will pay my state taxes but will not fund the murder of my fellow citizens nor will I fund the murder or attack on our NATO Allie's. I will also not line the Trump regimes pockets so I'm getting them done but I won't file. The money not that much sure but it's going into an account and when Trump is gone I'll catch up with the IRS. I'm done with this bullshit.
Apologies, there was a typo in this initial post. It is Renee Nicole Good and has been fixed.
Help identify the murderer, here's a computer generated composite of his face unmasked: https://substack.com/@lincolnsquare/note/c-196707491?
There's already an unmasked picture
Link?
Trump Has Killed More People Than First Realized
SO FAR...
Harry Thompson
News Reporter
PALM BEACH, FLORIDA - JANUARY 3: (EDITOR'S NOTE: This Handout image was provided by a third-party organization and may not adhere to Getty Images' editorial policy.) U.S. President Donald Trump, CIA Director John Ratcliffe (L) and Secretary of State Marco Rubio monitor U.S. military operations in Venezuela, from Trump's Mar-a-Lago Club on January 3, 2026 in Palm Beach, Florida. President of Venezuela Nicolas Maduro and first lady Cilia Flores were brought to New York on Saturday after being captured by the U.S. military in Caracas. They are expected to face federal charges related to drug trafficking and working with gangs designated as terrorist organizations.
Molly Riley/The White House via Getty
President Donald Trump’s military intervention in Venezuela claimed more lives than initially suspected, according to the country’s interior minister. Diosdado Cabello said on Wednesday that the operation to extricate dictator Nicolás Maduro and his wife claimed the lives of 100 people, despite the U.S. placing the initial death toll at 75, The Washington Post reports. “So far—and I say so far—there are 100 dead. One hundred. And a similar number injured,” he said. It is the first time Caracas has put a number on its dead, previously only stating the names of 23 slain service members, while Cuba, too, said 32 of its military personnel had died in the attack. Reuters reports that Venezuela also said large numbers of Maduro’s security detail were killed “in cold blood.” Cabello commenced a week of mourning for the fallen troops on Tuesday. CNBC reports that the Pentagon said seven U.S. service members were injured in the operation, five have recovered, and no fatalities have been announced.
Read it at Reuters
Now there's a surprise . . .NOT!
OMG.
https://www.bing.com/news/search?q=Picture+Of+The+ICE+Agent+Who+Killed+The+Lady+In+Minnesota&eventans=1&eventland=1&eventrel=1&qpvt=picture+of+the+ice+agent+who+killed+the+lady+in+Minnesoda&FORM=EWRE
Watch out for these:
<https://www.wired.com/story/people-are-using-ai-to-falsely-identify-the-federal-agent-who-shot-renee-good/>
Yeah, neither his identity nor picture has come out . . .YET! I'd be very surprised if it's not leaked in someway today.
Trigger happy macho fool
I cannot believe the taxpayer armament on those fools. They are cosplaying a war. Kristi's reality show from hell.
She's the reason they don't use dogs
They'd go after Kristi. Grrrr . . .
His name is Jonathan Ross. I saw it in an article this morning in the Minnesota Star Tribune.
Yes, hit the wires a few hours ago, I've been out. May he get a lifelong of unrest, there's not a place in the United State that he will be unidentifiable. I bet you, he's placed in a special relocation zone, outside of the continental. They're going to protect him at all costs.
The latest attempt to sanitize the murder is to use Ross’ previous experience of being dragged by a car as an excuse for being triggered. This is exactly why due process is so important, it is for the safety of all including the agents. NOEM is responsible for allowing due process to be violated. I have repeatedly written to my congressman members about the loss of due process and habeas corpus in immigration enforcement. The failure of GOPCongress to enforce this was the beginning of their succession from their duty. Abandoning the constitution, they left us while pretending so be our representatives. They are guilty also. This will continue to put agents in extremely compromised positions.
The ICE murderers name is Johnathan Ross. I believe the regime is protecting and has him in hiding. This is the second time he’s violated the law against an American citizen. In my opinion he needs hunted down, put him in jail until he’s put on trial for murder.
Yes, hit the wires a few hours ago, I've been out. May he get a lifelong of unrest, there's not a place in the United State that he will be unidentifiable. I bet you, he's placed in a special relocation zone, outside of the continental. They're going to protect him at all costs.
thank you... he must be ID'd. The hotels housing these nazi need to cancel their reservations immediately. Everyone should know where these goons are staying
That is exactly what I said. I don't care where they lay their head at night time, somebody needs to find out and a bunch of people need to either go there and start protesting and being loud or just driving by and blowing their horns keep the son of a bitches up all night long
I am delighted to hear that there are Articles of Impeachment for Noem. I know that you will be following that as you do everything important. Thanks for your consistently excellent journalism.
Johnathan Ross
Immigration and Customs Enforcement's Jonathan Ross. allegedly 10 years as ICE
You'd think he'd have better control of his emotions & that gun. She was driving away, he should have let her.
Is he insane . he has a spotfund me page !!! https://www.spotfund.com/story/65a8faaf-59e9-44ad-881c-e6fe41cde6a1
Great reporting, we need anything which could lead to him. But notice, no donors, no money. It's an ignored request with only a pic from the internet. Nothing on the internet to validate Marc Vojnic as being in Minnesota or an agent, it's a unique enough name that something would come up. I say it's b.s. somebody trying to capitalize on MAGA stupidity not to check it out and simply give over the red hat dollars; I applaud it, they are stupid enough to actually give. If you've been traveling the internet, there are people glorifying him and vilifying Renee. THEY ARE THAT STUPID!
Yes, thought the same!
If that is the perp's name (new to me), the Duck brought up top a fundraiser for poor Marc, who has been "unfairly targeted."
Sounds like a MAGA reaction.
The perps name is Johnathan Ross.
JUST LIKE THE VILLAINS IN THE EPSTEIN FILES, ACCOUNTABILITY IS A LIE. not every popsicle agent is following Criminal orders but putting 3 in the dome for traffic violations or federal crimes, is terrorism and we stop terrorists and violence in our homes, work places, airports & schools when it's happening. we don't "document and record". left&right are protected under 2A & it's our American duty to take necessary action to protect ourselves. our police officers aren't putting 3 in the dome for everyone who makes traffic violations or carries/under the influence of substances that are federal crimes. there are consequences to not following orders but 3 to the dome isnt one of them. we stop it at home, stop it at school and stop it in our airports. white skin and a mask does not prevent someone from being a threat. especially when that threat is so conspicuous and public. 2A isn't reserved for MAGA extremist with government jobs. Justice isnt reserved for the wealthy. you're worried about martial law but he already has all the power: he controls schools/universities, religion, lawyers, judicial branch, the military, the house, biggest monopoly corporations & the media. Earthlings stand up to terrorism regardless of skin, mask & jobs titles & we have 2A to thank for that. RIP Charlie Kirk
You fucked up big time.
Are we sure this is the murderer?
In respect to all the video available, there is no doubt as to which agent on site shot Renee. As I stated, this is a computer composite of his face unmasked from the video taken. Photo editing using AI has leaped to outrageous heights in just the last year; it is possible he has a goatee, beard, mustache but, the shape is essentially going to be on target. My hope is somebody knows an ice agent that looks essentially like the guy in the photo. We need to do the work ourselves since, as of the news reports this morning, Minneapolis AND Minnesota law enforcement has been officially locked out of the investigation or even getting any information on the investigation; it has been handed solely to the FBI. You already know the circus and joke that investigation is going to be!
May this ICE officer (Gestapo )and his family know no peace for the rest of their lives
The guy shot her three times! Once through the windshield and then moved over to shoot her two times through the drivers window. This was an execution, plain and simple. Three times, point blank.
Manslaughter
Murder.
Yes. I think it was murder as well. The shooter should be in jail right now.
No. I think it was murder.
Murder is a plan to kill.
Shooting at someone at point blank range and pointing at their head is a plan to kill.
Yes, unless this ICE officer said something about wanting to kill someone -- even a general comment -- ahead of this event. That would be sorted out at trial, of course.
He didn't shoot her just once to disable her. He shot her three times to end her and it was his choice to do so. To me , that is not manslaughter but rather murder. i.e. the killing was not accidental.
No that’s premeditated murder. Johnathan Ross intent is to murder Ms Good.
Glenn Kirschner said it was a criminal homicide. Prosecutors will decide if it’s second degree murder or manslaughter.
No. This was MURDER. Using the right words is critically important right now.
I saw the horrific video and thought the reaction by ICE was clearly uncalled for . I am so saddened by this murder by a hardened professional with a gun and a willingness to kill with reckless abandon, it would seem. How will this be explained to the children? They are going to need much counselling ,as will others in the family, to deal with the rage and unimaginable grief after something like this, as hate foments hate .
Robert, he should be arrested and charged for murder! And Noem impeached!
An eye for eye.
I hope her spirit comes and stands at the edge of that "agent's" bed for the rest of his miserable life, may it be short and painful.
Yesss!
Let it be!!
Exactly!!!!!!
Hate is hate! Our division will not be resolved through more hate. I know it’s hard, I do, but there’s a better way forward that doesn’t make us hate those we disagree with or dislike.
Really? Whether you like it or not, a lot of social and political progress has been achieved PRECISELY because of hate.
One caveat was - it was great hate combined with great love. When slaves and people who took up their cause fought against slavery, it wasn't because they found slavery mildly inconvenient. They hated it. That great hate was combined with great love for their fellow humans and their freedom.
Women didn't get beaten and imprisoned because they thought their lack of rights was a mere nuisance - they HATED the fact that they were being treated as inferior beings.
Right now, my fellow Ukrainians are not fighting Russia because they are annoyed - they hate that some big bully came barging into their country, committed hideous atrocities, and wants to get away with it and then some. This hate too is combined with their great love of their land and their independence.
Hate has its place - and I strongly believe it has its place here and now. We SHOULD hate these people for what they have done and what they continue to do. Because we also love those, whom they abuse and oppress. We SHOULD hate autocracy. We SHOULD hate abuse of power. Pretending like it's a mere disagreement is not going to get us anywhere. This is a serious problem and it will not be solved by the "let's all hold hands - we are still friends" attitude. We are talking about human rights violations here. That is not just a disagreement or dislike.
I had no idea I was capable of hating this deeply and this extends to my country for twice voting for a president who is evil to the core.
You make some valid points on the power that drives change. You’re not wrong on several points regarding the duality of love and hate. However, I have pursued much inspiration from the civil right movement of the 60s, specifically the approach taken by Dr. MLK, Jr. who also understood the corrosion of hate on a community and on individuals. How are we better than the hate driving ICE agents to mistreat, abuse, and harm people if we also support similar hate ourselves?
Not similar hate. They hate people for things outside of people's control. We hate them for what they do because of it. People have no choice in where they are born, or what color they are, or what sexual orientation. ICE agents have a choice whether to be what they are or not.
Yes, they do have a choice.
I agree.
Hate is not the same as anger. Anger fueled by attack or threat to someone or something you love can strengthen resolve and motivate to constructive action. Hate is hardened anger that has lost its way.
I hate Putin, Trump, and a few other people, and I know exactly why. I haven't lost my way. Some people deserve to be hated and I am happy to provide that service. If my refusal to shy away from hate and what it entails makes anyone uncomfortable - you are free not to join me. I have a great capacity for hate and a great capacity for love, and I embrace both.
I'm with you Maria K. I hate Trump and Putin more than I thought I could hate. They are a stain on mankind. They are as evil as cancer!
Yup, that's what I've been comparing them to as well. And we have no reason not to hate cancer. I lost my mom to a bone tumor, lost friends to cancer as well. I hate what it does and I want it gone. Its only saving grace is - it doesn't know what it's doing, but THESE people do. Which makes it worse.
I choose to not join you, Maria.
It appears that you have become them .
Gee, thanks a lot! Because, obviously, you know everything about me and what I do and it is TOTALLY the same as hunting immigrants for sport and shooting innocent civilians. Well done! Enjoy piling more people into the same bucket!
EXCELLENT....GOOD POINT
Maria, I feel for you and your country as you have had to deal with so much injustice by the Russians led by Putin , to the enrichment of the oligarchs that he pays homage to. Your hate , and that of your country , has obviously kept you fighting for your freedom to be a sovereign country for many years now.
My heart tells me to stand up to the wrong being done now in our country with righteous resolve and determination to right wrongs being perpetrate in our country by hateful Christian Nationalists people who love to hate and live to hate on a daily basis.
We, as Americans, must not become like them.
What I see as the solution to all of what is happening is to stand united as We,The People , against a fascist regime that wishes to overtake us and become our overlords for their own personal enrichment . Protests are a good thing and when done within the law and in an orderly manner can be a starting point toward a more just society by energizing voters to get the facts straight on the current issues that we are all facing in our country and vote out the trouble makers and vote in the sound thinkers who wish for a fair and equitable life in our country in accord with our Preamble, our Constitution and our Bill of Rights.
I'm with you and your people in your fight for these things and I want the best for you and yours for many years to come.
Thank you. I am actually in the States - I am a first-generation Ukrainian-American. My parents are in the war-torn, daily-bombed Zaporizhzhya, and I can't get them out. Meanwhile, they are worried about me because I am a female neurodivergent immigrant living in the United States today - the LAST thing they should be worrying about, really, since they get shelled every day.
I am very aware and am part of the resistance effort here - supporting indie journalists like Aaron here, daily educating people about the situation in Ukraine, writing to my representatives, etc.
So, I am having double the fun wondering if my parents are still alive on an hourly basis and getting my personal share of hate for being an immigrant. All because of certain people's drive for money and power. I do not advocate violence - although, I am 100% rooting for my step-mom who said that, if Russians come barging into Zaporizhzhya, she would fight them off with her favorite cast iron frying pan. However, I reserve my right to hate and channel that feeling in whatever way I see necessary.
RIGHT NOW, people are trying to protect their families,neighbors,friends from danger. That's the opposite of the hate that you speak of. They are doing as we are told to do," LOVE ❤️ thy neighbor."
The original comment was about wishing no peace on the accused gunman or his family for the rest of their lives. That’s not love or a viable solution to our division. You’re right, love is the answer but we must also provide it to those seemingly unworthy of our love and compassion to rise above the hate driving these horrific crimes! The point is that our anger, fear, and frustration, among other things, can result in hate within ourselves as well, which is not the way!
The gunman had just destroyed a family, a neighborhood, and a circle of friends. At the very least, I hope his family walks away from him and his friends turn away from him, and he goes to jail for murder.
From what I have learned to date about this situation , it appears to me that he is guilty of murder and should go to jail for that.
Sadly, the powers that be are already spinning this as "self defense" and slandering the murdered woman as "disorderly" and the person who filmed the video - a "professional agitator".
The hatred that “is driving these horrific crimes” was started and continues to be fed by donald trump. His “truth social” rants to his followers and his public statements drive the hatred. There is something inside of these people who follow him and commit these atrocities that matches his anger and hatred. Whether it is a feeling of being displaced in the work place or bigotry against non white people, I don’t know. Right now these people are full of hate and are complicit with these crimes.
They are White Supremacists. That is what they do.
Yes, but trump has Hispanic followers, too. Also some gay and black followers. I can’t get my head around that.
Okay, Skippy. That's a lot of words to shove down the throats of the many of us grieving America's, 👋
✌️💙
Go to DC with your load and preach to the Trump Regime. 👏
Well said.
In reference to my "well said" I was referring to the Love, Thy Neighbor comment that you made, dee Ramero.
Yes.
I agree, TN.
Why their families?
You can’t know what the rest of his family’s political persuasion is yet so until you find out, they fairly shouldn’t be included. You know there are millions of divided family political views in this horrible time. Then if it’s found out they inspired this mentality… go for it!
For right now concentrate on that poor child, now without her mother. And find the devil who inflicted this unbelievable horror
That little boy, age 6, is now an orphan. His father, and the husband of his mother, died a few years ago.
The ICE “agents” are thugs. Look at all of the examples we have seen of their actions. They show no compassion at all for those that they grab off the streets, leaving children alone, without parents.
(I made an error, her child is a boy. I corrected it. )
The upsetting thing is that they get away with it___the government has done nothing to improve the situation for almost a year_____it reallly is inhumane____the victims are human beings !!!
You are absolutely correct....brutal thugs....with no human emotions
I have been reading that she had three children. The six year old was probably the youngest that she was dropping off at school or day care. Thank god she didn't have him in the car.
Also thank god that she didn't hit someone else and kill or injure them when she crashed. THAT'S would have been on the ICE agent.
What? I'm having trouble following you, EaB.
I'm still on the woman in Minnesota who was killed and had three kids. What am I missing?
Joseph, I was answering the earlier post above that said that the ICE shooter’s family should know no peace for the rest of their lives.
Him? Absolutely!
We don’t know anything about his family so I feel we shouldn’t be judging them until all the facts are revealed about him, the monster who created this moral and criminal disaster. Families nowadays are so divided in their beliefs so we should wait and see if they’re in league with him. Then feel free to express your wishes if they were like minded to his ideals.
I submit that some people are just born with psychological disorders that exhibit themselves through the abhorrent behavior of many of the Nazi types in the world , in my opinion.
💯 % I'm separated from my sisters,nephews,
my twin brother, and until 2021( my dad RIP). I know how difficult and divisive it is.
Why go for it EaB ?
Oh, this will haunt him for the rest of his life on this earth.
I doubt that! These types of people do not feel remorse or shame
Psychopaths don't feel anything.
Agreed, ANY PERSON WHO CAN FIRE 3 BULLETS INTO A PERSON, HAS NO conscience!!!!!!!!
Help identify the murderer, here's a computer generated composite of his face unmasked: https://substack.com/@lincolnsquare/note/c-196707491?
Amen 🙏
The lady's family in Minnesota should file a lawsuit against Trump and Nome sue Trump for $500 Million for murder, and NOME for $500 Million for murder. These goons have to be stopped before more people are killed without cause.
Lock Donald Trump up before more people are killed.;
Trump Has Killed More People Than First Realized
SO FAR...
PALM BEACH, FLORIDA - JANUARY 3: (EDITOR'S NOTE: This Handout image was provided by a third-party organization and may not adhere to Getty Images' editorial policy.) U.S. President Donald Trump, CIA Director John Ratcliffe (L) and Secretary of State Marco Rubio monitor U.S. military operations in Venezuela, from Trump's Mar-a-Lago Club on January 3, 2026 in Palm Beach, Florida. President of Venezuela Nicolas Maduro and first lady Cilia Flores were brought to New York on Saturday after being captured by the U.S. military in Caracas. They are expected to face federal charges related to drug trafficking and working with gangs designated as terrorist organizations.
Molly Riley/The White House via Getty
President Donald Trump’s military intervention in Venezuela claimed more lives than initially suspected, according to the country’s interior minister. Diosdado Cabello said on Wednesday that the operation to extricate dictator Nicolás Maduro and his wife claimed the lives of 100 people, despite the U.S. placing the initial death toll at 75, The Washington Post reports. “So far—and I say so far—there are 100 dead. One hundred. And a similar number injured,” he said. It is the first time Caracas has put a number on its dead, previously only stating the names of 23 slain service members, while Cuba, too, said 32 of its military personnel had died in the attack. Reuters reports that Venezuela also said large numbers of Maduro’s security detail were killed “in cold blood.” Cabello commenced a week of mourning for the fallen troops on Tuesday. CNBC reports that the Pentagon said seven U.S. service members were injured in the operation, five have recovered, and no fatalities have been announced.
Read it at Reuters
Get back on Jeffrey Epstein files and the raping of underage girls by Epstein and his friends
Echo-I agree the ICE officer (Gestapo) should know no peace, but his wife and kids?Really?They are not guilty by association. They are not guilty at all.
I have been wondering for months how the parents of these evil spawn feel about the direction in life their kids have taken.
Amen in the name of Jesus I AM in Agreement with THAT 💯 PERCENT
Why hasn’t there been an arrest of the officer who murdered this woman?
He simply got in a car and drove off. So much for a crime scene
This should NEVER have happened. These thugs escalated the situation instead of defusing it. Why put yourself into a situation that is a direct line to discharging your firearm?? Step away let the vehicle leave, you have the license plate number, arrest when it's safe for all. These thugs are trigger-happy goons. An independent entity needs to gather as many videos possible and analyze completely. Get a warrant for the medical record of this thug before this administration gets it and alters it. They hopefully made him relinquish his firearm until a full and independent and complete investigation is performed.
There was a physician who offered to look at the victim, but these thugs would not allow it. They knew this was a CRIME
He didn't even remain at tbe scene
He’ll probably get a bonus, if noem or trump have their way. These actions are to tell those who could protest and make a difference: your actions will not be tolerated, and you may pay for your opposition with your life.
They are trying to scare us into submission.
Will we ever wake up to tranquility instead of chaos?
In the grave___like Renee Nicole Good
Yes.
So much for needing to be admitted to the hospital as cosplay Barbie claimed. Let’s hear the doctor’s evaluation of injuries.
Which hospital. The video has been slowed down second by second. There is no contact
🤬🤬🤬🤬
Because her execution was sanctioned by the United States government.
Keith Ellison was just on CNN and the state law enforcement that supposed to work in conjunction with the FBI have been told to stand down. Gestapo regime tactics. My hope is eventually when the FBI finishes their fake investigation local and state law enforcement will do their investigations. Eventually this murderer will be held accountable. We should definitely try find out who it is.
Because he fled the scene!
It's my understanding that Kristi Noam said he shot her in self defense, as she was going to hit him and anybody else in her attempt to escape, is the rationale for his actions. Video review would reveal otherwise. I saw the video and she actually tried to steer away from him after he made the first shot and got out of the way to go to her driver side window and shoot her twice in the head.
Let’s call it what it is: a public execution!
It was murder, in plain sight!🤬🤬🤬 Prayers to her loved ones🙏🏼
JUSTICE FOR RENEE NICOLE GOOD!
Yes.
Arrest this “officer”
Arrest Noem.
She wore a cowboy hat when she announced this was an act of terrorism. That is blatant contempt
Probably wore that same hat when she shot the puppy in the pit. Happy memories.
What is it about her and her costumes. She is disgusting.
She's fake on the inside and most definitely on the outside. Her body can't anymore plastic surgery botox or lip fillers she's gross in more ways than one!
Yes, and hold his manager and his manager's manager to account for setting up conditions so that someone would get hurt. He did wrong, but he's a pawn. Don't let the managers get away with it. They'll just go ahead and send other pawns in, and more people will get hurt. Unnecessarily, needlessly hurt.
Stephen Miller is the mastermind of this behavior. He will burn in hell.
Bovine was out harassing Uber drivers. He is not the commanding officer on site.
i hope the “officer” never knows a second of peace in his insignificant life. there will be so much karma that comes for him may it be fierce
Renee Nicole Good
Impeach the lying monster. Noem.
So get ready for Marshall law, this is the lie Bubble Gut will use.
Martial law
Thank you for the correction spelling I was so pissed I couldn’t think of the correct spelling, but I hope people understood what I meant.
I did, Joyce.
Bring it on! I’m not going to obey in advance for fear of it. If he does something like that (catalyst) the repercussions would be huge! Bring it on!
Ice and Noam are murderers.........they should all be charged but knowing your DOJ they won't do a thing...........welcome to the US
I did not sleep well last night over this.
I think I may end up leaving my 10 year significant other over this.
A profound difference?
It took me awhile, too.
Omg if they extend subsidies, I may have hope for our Congress just yet…. But god help us bc I don’t know if they’ll do enough.
Nicole Renee Good was already a widow - SO that means her little daughter is now an ORPHAN. The story only gets worse!
Her 6 year old has a parent. Renee has a wife surviving her. She miraculously survived the shooting in the car although she was sprayed with her wife’s blood.
O M G insanity ‼️
Yes. Renee was widowed in 2023 and the child is from that union but thank goodness the child still has a parent right now. I read early on an interview of her wife who sat on a nearby curb clutching their dog who said she didn’t know what she was going to do, that they had a 6 year old in school…and the blood. This is the person draped over and holding Renee sobbing in videos after the car had hit the pole. And yes, she is a first hand witness who said they had only stopped to video ICE. I can only think her shock, privacy protection, safety from nut jobs, and protection against ICE (who might try to arrest her as “complicit” in some way because they have labeled their victim Renee as a terrorist) is why the circumstances of her presence and existence is not generally known. Can you imagine Minnesotan locals (mayor) setting the trap for ICE lies by keeping the main eyewitness under protection and quiet until she can spring the truth on the murderer in a court?
I'm sorry. I didn't know about her wife being there. I read so many news articles that are not consistent, including the name of her mother (2 different names). He does have a grandfather who spends time with the little boy. He said that he's the only man in his grandson's Iife. I didn't watch the video because I can't handle that. Thank you for all the info. So heartbreaking. I really hate this entire administration. They are evil.
No apologies necessary. The reporter on site could have misunderstood too. 😢 we’re all very sad and angry. And it’s probably a good thing for you not to tattoo those images on your brain. I already have all the regrets. I knew Alito’s mother who exposed the corruption to me during the 80’s (which came to pass just as she told me it would), and tRump owes me money from back then too. Thank goodness I was warned away from him and his crowd when I used to go to NY. I knew Forbes Sr (who was generous unlike his tight son who even tried to have his gay father committed to get the $). I did some protesting when I was young and I was also beat up (before Rodney King or videos, but I won all my cases and the largest settlement of its kind to that date in that state). I have all this corruption and the inside of the beehive in my neurons already. Bedminster (which is a town between Oldwick and Peapack-Gladstone/Bernardsville where now he owns that golf course) was one of my stomping grounds. All these things being perpetrated on all of us are disillusioning, very real, and have been going on for decades. My heart breaks anew for poor Renee. I can barely handle what her last moments must have been like for her when they murdered her and stole her life.
https://www.advocate.com/news/minnesota-ice-killed-wife
Sadly, she may become a target.
I hope not with my whole heart. That mayor should be providing her and the kid(s) with meaningful protection who won’t look the other way or cave to feds.
I read that she had three kids.
I read that elsewhere too.
My guess they haven’t turned him over yet is because they are trying to hide him. They know he will be tried for murder and the Republicans don’t want that optic. Anybody know someone who has access to facial recognition? That’s about the fastest way to find him unless someone knows him and thinks he is a POS. A Trump POS belongs in the trash heap of history.
I don't know anyone else I will pay my state taxes but will not fund the murder of my fellow citizens nor will I fund the murder or attack on our NATO Allie's. I will also not line the Trump regimes pockets so I'm getting them done but I won't file. The money not that much sure but it's going into an account and when Trump is gone I'll catch up with the IRS. I'm done with this bullshit.